ATTI Shadow Tracker vs. Fleetio: Which is Best?

ATTI Shadow Tracker vs. Fleetio: Which is Best?

ATTI Shadow Tracker vs. Fleetio Best Overall: Fleetio

In our comparison of ATTI Shadow Tracker vs. Fleetio, Fleetio is the best option with a higher overall Wheelhouse Score. Wheelhouse Score uses a combination of feature and pricing comparison data, average user ratings, and editorial reviews to score software vendors on a scale of 1-10.

Quick Info

ATTI Shadow Tracker Quick Info
WH Score:
7.7
Pricing Score:
7.3
Feature Score:
7.1
Usability Score:
7.7
Company Size:Small Business, Mid Market
Platforms:
Fleetio Quick Info
WH Score:
8.3
Pricing Score:
7.9
Feature Score:
8.3
Usability Score:
7.5
Company Size:All Sizes
Platforms:

Pricing

ATTI Shadow Tracker Pricing
Price Range
Contact Us

* Vendor does not share prices.

Fleetio Pricing
Essential
$4
per vehicle / per month
Professional
$7
per vehicle / per month
Premium
$10
per vehicle / per month

Features

ATTI Shadow Tracker Features
  • Fleet Repair/Maintenance Management
  • Fleet Lifecycle Management
  • Route Planning
  • Traffic/Cancellation Response
  • Driver Scorecards
  • GPS Tracking
  • Speed Tracking
  • Route Deviation Tracking
  • Geofencing
  • OBD Trackers
  • Fleet Safety Training Programs
  • Sales & Purchase Orders
  • Vendor/Supplier Management
  • Order/Delivery Management
  • Equipment/Tools Management
Fleetio Features
  • Fleet Repair/Maintenance Management
  • Fleet Lifecycle Management
  • Route Planning
  • Traffic/Cancellation Response
  • Driver Scorecards
  • GPS Tracking
  • Speed Tracking
  • Route Deviation Tracking
  • Geofencing
  • OBD Trackers
  • Fleet Safety Training Programs
  • Sales & Purchase Orders
  • Vendor/Supplier Management
  • Order/Delivery Management
  • Equipment/Tools Management

Pros & Cons

ATTI Shadow Tracker Pros & Cons
Pros
  • Digesting the information is simple, it is simple to get a snapshot of driving behavior and both routes thanks to the fast view of driver speeds on the map using colors to display speed ranges, depending on your desires intervals, you can track stops, ability to track drivers on the fly thanks to the exceptional phone app feature, we monitor our small fleet in an economical manner, and adding Geofences can offer a sense of safety when trucks are packed for a whole weekend or evening and allows alerts pertinent to designated places.
Cons
  • Has a standard, non-web-based UI, tech support is terrible, and you have to use the tracker they ship to you as changing your contract or sending it back is not possible.
Fleetio Pros & Cons
Pros
  • It is full of useful features
  • It fits the specific needs of every company regardless of the nature of the job.
Cons
  • The slow times are there
  • Many of the features are on maintenance permanently so are of no use.

Reviews

ATTI Shadow Tracker Reviews
Top Favorable Review
F
Frank
Reviewed on Jul 2, 2021

Shadow Tracker provided a firm, cheap method to monitor our small fleet because we pay per truck. Also, since the tracking and data storage is readily available and doesn’t need any thought, we’ve considered adding trackers to more trucks.

Digesting the information is simple, it is simple to get a snapshot of driving behavior and both routes thanks to the fast view of driver speeds on the map using colors to display speed ranges, depending on your desires intervals, you can track stops, ability to track drivers on the fly thanks to the exceptional phone app feature, we monitor our small fleet in an economical manner, and adding Geofences can offer a sense of safety when trucks are packed for a whole weekend or evening and allows alerts pertinent to designated places.

Partially intuitive UI, a rather outdated layout.

Top Critical Review
J
Jeffrey
Reviewed on Jul 2, 2021

The client service is very horrible. I wouldn’t propose this software to any person at all.

The equipment is free.

Has a standard, non-web-based UI, tech support is terrible, and you have to use the tracker they ship to you as changing your contract or sending it back is not possible.

Fleetio Reviews
Top Favorable Review
A
Alan
Reviewed on Jul 2, 2021

I like this tool very much and would recommend it to all businesses. The training and implementation process can be made better.

It is full of useful features. It fits the specific needs of every company regardless of the nature of the job.

More features should be added. It needs a bit more customization. Data input is not clear.

Top Critical Review
J
Jamie
Reviewed on Jul 2, 2021

The custom inspection forms based on the type of delivery service can be created without any trouble. The integration of fuel with WEX fuel is great. Constant updates are impressive.

The slow times are there. Many of the features are on maintenance permanently so are of no use.

Alternatives

ATTI Shadow Tracker Alternatives
7.5
Fleetio Alternatives
7.5
Add to Compare

Add suggested to comparison

ATTI Shadow Tracker vs. Fleetio: Detailed Comparison

ATTI Shadow Tracker vs. Fleetio Top Ratings & Reviews: Fleetio

In our rating and review comparison of ATTI Shadow Tracker vs. Fleetio, Fleetio has 52 user reviews and ATTI Shadow Tracker has 5. The average star rating for Fleetio is 4.78 while ATTI Shadow Tracker has an average rating of 3.2. Fleetio has more positive reviews than ATTI Shadow Tracker. Comparing ATTI Shadow Tracker vs. Fleetio reviews, Fleetio has stronger overall reviews.

ATTI Shadow Tracker vs. Fleetio Best Features & Functionality: Fleetio

ATTI Shadow Tracker vs. Fleetio both offer a strong set of features and functionality including Fleet Management, Driver Management, Telematics, Accounting Features, Inventory Management, Customizable Items, Reminders/Alerts, Report Management, Reporting & Analytics, Systems/Administrative, Identity and Access Management (IAM), Integration Options, After-Sales Service. In our feature comparison of ATTI Shadow Tracker vs. Fleetio, Fleetio offers more of the most popular features and tools than ATTI Shadow Tracker.

ATTI Shadow Tracker vs. Fleetio Best Pricing: Fleetio

In our pricing comparison of ATTI Shadow Tracker vs. Fleetio, Fleetio's pricing starts at $4/month and is more affordable compared to Fleetio's starting cost of $4/month.

ATTI Shadow Tracker vs. Fleetio Best Usability: ATTI Shadow Tracker

Our comparison of ATTI Shadow Tracker vs. Fleetio shows that ATTI Shadow Tracker scores higher in usability for meets requirements, setup & support. Fleetio scores higher in ease of use, learning curve, quality of support, ease of admin, but ATTI Shadow Tracker has the best scores overall for system usability.

The right software for your business

Get your personalized recommendations now.