Paychex Flex Time vs. TimeClock Plus: Which is Best?

Paychex Flex Time vs. TimeClock Plus: Which is Best?

Paychex Flex Time vs. TimeClock Plus Best Overall: TimeClock Plus

In our comparison of Paychex Flex Time vs. TimeClock Plus, TimeClock Plus is the best option with a higher overall Wheelhouse Score. Wheelhouse Score uses a combination of feature and pricing comparison data, average user ratings, and editorial reviews to score software vendors on a scale of 1-10.

Quick Info

Paychex Flex Time Quick Info
WH Score:
7.8
Pricing Score:
7.2
Feature Score:
7.3
Usability Score:
7.2
Company Size:All Sizes
Platforms:
TimeClock Plus Quick Info
WH Score:
8.4
Pricing Score:
8.1
Feature Score:
7.7
Usability Score:
7.7
Company Size:All Sizes
Platforms:

Pricing

Paychex Flex Time Pricing
Price Range
Contact Us

* Vendor does not share prices.

TimeClock Plus Pricing
Price Range
Contact Us

* Vendor does not share prices.

Features

Paychex Flex Time Features
  • Timesheets
  • Time Off Management
  • Break Management
  • Attendance Geofencing
  • Forecasting
  • Time Off Reports
  • Mileage Tracking
  • Dashboard
  • Geographical Reporting
  • Accrual Reports
  • Employee Records
  • Employee Onboarding/Offboarding
  • Biometric
  • App-Based
  • Paystubs
TimeClock Plus Features
  • Timesheets
  • Time Off Management
  • Break Management
  • Attendance Geofencing
  • Forecasting
  • Time Off Reports
  • Mileage Tracking
  • Dashboard
  • Geographical Reporting
  • Accrual Reports
  • Employee Records
  • Employee Onboarding/Offboarding
  • Biometric
  • App-Based
  • Paystubs

Pros & Cons

Paychex Flex Time Pros & Cons
Pros
  • So, what I like best about Paychex Flex is their amazing customer service
  • Whenever I send an email to their dedicated representatives, they get back to me quickly with thorough and correct explanations
  • Plus, when it comes to PPP loan forgiveness, Paychex Flex provides all the information I need.
Cons
  • Although it may be suitable for small companies, I found the UI to be quite outdated, and the reporting features were lacking.
TimeClock Plus Pros & Cons
Pros
  • It is so easy to use, and there are lots of functions that work well
  • Some functions, however, do not work as perfectly.
Cons
  • There were some issues with setting up the clock right, especially the way we wanted to set it up to work with Single Sign-On
  • Their customer support was not able to help us initially either.

Reviews

Paychex Flex Time Reviews
Top Favorable Review
T
Thomas
Reviewed on Jul 2, 2021

One of the problems that Paychex solves for us is payroll management. Thanks to Paychex, we have a hands-off approach to payroll, which is both accurate and automatic. Our employees also appreciate how hassle-free it is.

So, what I like best about Paychex Flex is their amazing customer service. Whenever I send an email to their dedicated representatives, they get back to me quickly with thorough and correct explanations. Plus, when it comes to PPP loan forgiveness, Paychex Flex provides all the information I need.

I have to say that the Paychex Flex interface looks like it's from way back in the early 2000s! It can be tough to figure out where to click to find what you're looking for.

Top Critical Review
R
Rocio
Reviewed on Jul 2, 2021

I would highly recommend this product for small businesses, but it may not be able to scale as needed for larger companies.

I really enjoyed using the time card feature in the system. The system was incredibly intuitive and it was easy for me to figure out any issues with payroll.

Although it may be suitable for small companies, I found the UI to be quite outdated, and the reporting features were lacking.

TimeClock Plus Reviews
Top Favorable Review
W
William
Reviewed on Jul 2, 2021

It is so easy to use, and there are lots of functions that work well. Some functions, however, do not work as perfectly.

The client service is not exactly great. We have had relatively simple answers, and we have had a hard time getting hold of people to help us. Any change in the directly assigned account representatives from the company can result in a loss of contact with the right support staff, which is what happened with us.

Top Critical Review
T
Therese
Reviewed on Jul 2, 2021

We had issues with the installation and basic set up with some integration. Once installed though, the software was not too bad to work with from there.

It provides the basic functionality for which it is purchased. It is low in price.

There were some issues with setting up the clock right, especially the way we wanted to set it up to work with Single Sign-On. Their customer support was not able to help us initially either.

Alternatives

Paychex Flex Time Alternatives
TimeClock Plus Alternatives
Add to Compare

Add suggested to comparison

Paychex Flex Time vs. TimeClock Plus: Detailed Comparison

Paychex Flex Time vs. TimeClock Plus Top Ratings & Reviews: TimeClock Plus

In our rating and review comparison of Paychex Flex Time vs. TimeClock Plus, TimeClock Plus has 26 user reviews and Paychex Flex Time has 13. The average star rating for TimeClock Plus is 4.07 while Paychex Flex Time has an average rating of 3.30. TimeClock Plus has more positive reviews than Paychex Flex Time. Comparing Paychex Flex Time vs. TimeClock Plus reviews, TimeClock Plus has stronger overall reviews.

Paychex Flex Time vs. TimeClock Plus Best Features & Functionality: TimeClock Plus

Paychex Flex Time vs. TimeClock Plus both offer a strong set of features and functionality including Attendance Management, Human Resources (HR) Features, Reporting & Analytics, Clock-In/Clock-Out Options, Project Management Features, Customizable Items, Appointments/Scheduling, Language & Speech. In our feature comparison of Paychex Flex Time vs. TimeClock Plus, TimeClock Plus offers more of the most popular features and tools than Paychex Flex Time.

Paychex Flex Time vs. TimeClock Plus Best Pricing: TimeClock Plus

In our pricing comparison of Paychex Flex Time vs. TimeClock Plus, TimeClock Plus's pricing starts at 0/month and is more affordable compared to TimeClock Plus's starting cost of 0/month.

Paychex Flex Time vs. TimeClock Plus Best Usability: TimeClock Plus

Our comparison of Paychex Flex Time vs. TimeClock Plus shows that TimeClock Plus scores higher in usability for ease of use, learning curve, setup & support, quality of support, ease of admin. Paychex Flex Time scores higher in meets requirements, but TimeClock Plus has the best scores overall for system usability.

The right software for your business

Get your personalized recommendations now.