CallRail vs. Nextiva: Which is Best? - Wheelhouse

CallRail vs. Nextiva: Which is Best?

CallRail vs. Nextiva Best Overall: CallRail

In our comparison of CallRail vs. Nextiva, CallRail is the best option with a higher overall Wheelhouse Score. Wheelhouse Score uses a combination of feature and pricing comparison data, average user ratings, and editorial reviews to score software vendors on a scale of 1-10.

Quick Info

CallRail Quick Info
WH Score:
8.4
Pricing Score:
7.6
Feature Score:
7.8
Usability Score:
8.2
Company Size:All Sizes
Platforms:
Nextiva Quick Info
WH Score:
8.3
Pricing Score:
8.1
Feature Score:
7.8
Usability Score:
7.9
Company Size:All Sizes
Platforms:

Pricing

CallRail Pricing
Call Tracking
Free
per number / per month
Call Tracking + Conversation Intelligence
Free
per number / per month
Call Tracking + Form Tracking
Free
per number / per month
Call Tracking Complete
Free
per number / per month
Nextiva Pricing
Essential
$17.95
per user / per month
Professional
$21.95
per user / per month
Enterprise
$31.95
per user / per month

Features

CallRail Features
  • Artificial Intelligence (AI)
  • Machine Learning (ML)
  • Conversation Intelligence (CI)
  • Transcriptions
  • Call Log Reports
  • SEO & Keyword Tracking
  • Call Analytics
  • Sentiment Analysis
  • Email Reports
  • Lead and Opportunity Tracking
  • Conversation Analytics
  • Call Scoring
  • Dynamic Number Insertion (DNI)
  • Local Numbers
  • Toll-Free Numbers
Nextiva Features
  • Artificial Intelligence (AI)
  • Machine Learning (ML)
  • Conversation Intelligence (CI)
  • Transcriptions
  • Call Log Reports
  • SEO & Keyword Tracking
  • Call Analytics
  • Sentiment Analysis
  • Email Reports
  • Lead and Opportunity Tracking
  • Conversation Analytics
  • Call Scoring
  • Dynamic Number Insertion (DNI)
  • Local Numbers
  • Toll-Free Numbers

Pros & Cons

CallRail Pros & Cons
Pros
  • Provides invaluable insight into how our marketing leads are handled by our customer team.
Cons
  • I have found that the interface for setting up accounts/clients is confusing
  • If I am trying to use an umbrella account that houses multiple clients, it can get very confusing as to where I am in the process
  • I have had to contact Call Rail to activate and deactivate accounts and refund charges for accounts that weren't supposed to be live because the platform was not intuitive and set up incorrectly.
Nextiva Pros & Cons
Pros
  • The desk phones are easy to register and the client support is really good
  • It is a relatively inexpensive solution considering the reliability of the communication network, the level of service provision, and the terms offered for service utilization.
Cons
  • Despite being dissatisfied with the prices, breaking free required persistent efforts, numerous calls, and the involvement of a manager who didn't initially follow through
  • The experience of leaving Nextiva was far from smooth, emphasizing caution for potential customers.

Reviews

CallRail Reviews
Top Favorable Review
S
Stephanie
Reviewed on Jul 2, 2021

CallRail is a great tool for gaining insights into lead generation and customer experience.

Provides invaluable insight into how our marketing leads are handled by our customer team.

Inability to generate reports based on this data is a limitation.

Top Critical Review
G
Guadalupe
Reviewed on Jul 2, 2021

I am using this product to allow my clients to understand how advertising benefits call volume and listen to recorded messages for viable leads. The benefits I have realized include being able to analyze the effectiveness of advertising campaigns and identifying potential leads for my clients.

I find it easy to listen to recorded calls and set up new numbers using this product.

I have found that the interface for setting up accounts/clients is confusing. If I am trying to use an umbrella account that houses multiple clients, it can get very confusing as to where I am in the process. I have had to contact Call Rail to activate and deactivate accounts and refund charges for accounts that weren't supposed to be live because the platform was not intuitive and set up incorrectly.

Nextiva Reviews
Top Favorable Review
C
Chad
Reviewed on Jul 2, 2021

I had to give up some functionality to switch to this service from another big service provider, but the saving on the cost was well worth it. Overall, the key functionality works well, there are some issues, and the client support is excellent, so it is definitely a good and practical solution for us.

The desk phones are easy to register and the client support is really good. It is a relatively inexpensive solution considering the reliability of the communication network, the level of service provision, and the terms offered for service utilization.

There are issues with the software. For example, the text messages may arrive multiple times or many all together. Additionally, texts with pictures cannot be sent. Likewise, the contact synchronization process does not go smoothly and requires lots of added work to edit the contacts after syncing.

Top Critical Review
A
Allen
Reviewed on Jul 2, 2021

While technical support was responsive, the same cannot be said for customer support when it came to billing or contract issues. Exiting the contract was a cumbersome process as Nextiva failed to honor their end of the agreement.

Their phones arrived preset and the onboarding process was remarkably streamlined. Technical support was prompt and effective whenever issues arose.

Despite being dissatisfied with the prices, breaking free required persistent efforts, numerous calls, and the involvement of a manager who didn't initially follow through. The experience of leaving Nextiva was far from smooth, emphasizing caution for potential customers.

Alternatives

CallRail Alternatives
Nextiva Alternatives
Add to Compare

Add suggested to comparison

CallRail vs. Nextiva: Detailed Comparison

CallRail vs. Nextiva Top Ratings & Reviews: CallRail

In our rating and review comparison of CallRail vs. Nextiva, CallRail has 9 user reviews and Nextiva has 66. The average star rating for CallRail is 4.66 while Nextiva has an average rating of 4.34. CallRail has more positive reviews than Nextiva. Comparing CallRail vs. Nextiva reviews, CallRail has stronger overall reviews.

CallRail vs. Nextiva Best Features & Functionality: Nextiva

CallRail vs. Nextiva both offer a strong set of features and functionality including Phone System Features, Call Management & Administration, Reporting & Analytics, Recording , Supported Technologies, Language & Speech, Chat/IM Management, Collaboration Tools, Supported Channels, Conferencing Capabilities, Remote Support Features, Enhancements & Personalization, Contact Management, Appointments/Scheduling, Device Management, Supported Devices/Hardware, Drag-and-Drop Builders/Designers, Third-Party Integrations, Microsoft 365, Google Workspace, Systems/Administrative, Identity and Access Management (IAM), After-Sales Service. In our feature comparison of CallRail vs. Nextiva, Nextiva offers more of the most popular features and tools than CallRail.

CallRail vs. Nextiva Best Pricing: Nextiva

In our pricing comparison of CallRail vs. Nextiva, Nextiva's pricing starts at $17.95/month and is more affordable compared to Nextiva's starting cost of $17.95/month.

CallRail vs. Nextiva Best Usability: CallRail

Our comparison of CallRail vs. Nextiva shows that CallRail scores higher in usability for ease of use, meets requirements, learning curve, setup & support, quality of support. Nextiva scores higher in ease of admin, but CallRail has the best scores overall for system usability.

The right software for your business

Get your personalized recommendations now.